Author |
Topic ![Next Topic Next Topic](images/icon_go_right.gif) |
Sergi
Member Rosenbergia
![](images/icon_star_blue.gif) ![](images/icon_star_blue.gif) ![](images/icon_star_blue.gif) ![](images/icon_star_blue.gif)
Spain
1741 Posts |
Posted - 25/01/2015 : 15:49:44
|
![](/public/imgforum/Sergi/2015125154831_z13.jpg) ![](/public/imgforum/Sergi/2015125154838_z14.jpg)
From China, Sichuan. Sizes: 16-17 mm respectively.
Maybe Grammographus notabilis cuneatus (Fairmaire, 1888)???? |
|
nasa
Member Rosalia
![](images/icon_star_cyan.gif) ![](images/icon_star_cyan.gif) ![](images/icon_star_cyan.gif)
China
960 Posts |
Posted - 25/01/2015 : 16:46:40
|
yes, it is! there are many similar topic about this species in the forum, you can find them! |
![Go to Top of Page Go to Top of Page](images/icon_go_up.gif) |
|
Xavier
Scientific Collaborator
![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif)
France
12085 Posts |
Posted - 25/01/2015 : 16:54:56
|
I still don't understand how to separe Demonax nigromaculatus Gahan, 1906 / Demonax oblongomaculatus Gahan, 1906 / Grammographus notabilis cuneatus (Fairmaire, 1888) etc |
![Go to Top of Page Go to Top of Page](images/icon_go_up.gif) |
|
Sergi
Member Rosenbergia
![](images/icon_star_blue.gif) ![](images/icon_star_blue.gif) ![](images/icon_star_blue.gif) ![](images/icon_star_blue.gif)
Spain
1741 Posts |
Posted - 25/01/2015 : 16:59:39
|
In Base Titan Demonax notabilis is synonym of Grammographus notabilis.![](images/icon_smile_question.gif) |
![Go to Top of Page Go to Top of Page](images/icon_go_up.gif) |
|
Francesco
Forum Admin
![](images/icon_star_gold.gif) ![](images/icon_star_gold.gif) ![](images/icon_star_gold.gif) ![](images/icon_star_gold.gif) ![](images/icon_star_gold.gif)
Luxembourg
9420 Posts |
Posted - 25/01/2015 : 17:03:52
|
Naturally, Grammographus is a well-known synonym of Demonax, as already explained here. |
![Go to Top of Page Go to Top of Page](images/icon_go_up.gif) |
|
Sergi
Member Rosenbergia
![](images/icon_star_blue.gif) ![](images/icon_star_blue.gif) ![](images/icon_star_blue.gif) ![](images/icon_star_blue.gif)
Spain
1741 Posts |
Posted - 25/01/2015 : 17:40:07
|
So, all Grammographus are Demonax?? |
![Go to Top of Page Go to Top of Page](images/icon_go_up.gif) |
|
Xavier
Scientific Collaborator
![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif)
France
12085 Posts |
Posted - 25/01/2015 : 19:05:21
|
Have a look here also ... |
Edited by - Xavier on 25/01/2015 19:05:35 |
![Go to Top of Page Go to Top of Page](images/icon_go_up.gif) |
|
Sergi
Member Rosenbergia
![](images/icon_star_blue.gif) ![](images/icon_star_blue.gif) ![](images/icon_star_blue.gif) ![](images/icon_star_blue.gif)
Spain
1741 Posts |
Posted - 25/01/2015 : 19:12:08
|
Very complicated these species.... All presents the same look!!![](images/icon_smile_dead.gif) |
![Go to Top of Page Go to Top of Page](images/icon_go_up.gif) |
|
Francesco
Forum Admin
![](images/icon_star_gold.gif) ![](images/icon_star_gold.gif) ![](images/icon_star_gold.gif) ![](images/icon_star_gold.gif) ![](images/icon_star_gold.gif)
Luxembourg
9420 Posts |
Posted - 26/01/2015 : 18:48:58
|
quote: Originally posted by Sergi
So, all Grammographus are Demonax??
Naturally, for the simple reason that the type-species (Grammographus lineatus Chevrolat, 1863) was synonymised with Demonax. All entomologists agree on this point for more than one century, as the same Titan base shows (here).
Then, if Mr. Tavakilian, on his own initiative, autonomously decides to conserve Grammophorus as a good genus, he must publish a paper supporting this statement. Otherwise, the officially recognized name remains Demonax notabilis. |
![Go to Top of Page Go to Top of Page](images/icon_go_up.gif) |
|
Xavier
Scientific Collaborator
![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif)
France
12085 Posts |
Posted - 26/01/2015 : 18:51:45
|
true ! |
![Go to Top of Page Go to Top of Page](images/icon_go_up.gif) |
|
Sergi
Member Rosenbergia
![](images/icon_star_blue.gif) ![](images/icon_star_blue.gif) ![](images/icon_star_blue.gif) ![](images/icon_star_blue.gif)
Spain
1741 Posts |
Posted - 26/01/2015 : 18:51:52
|
Ok Francesco, Thank you very much for your clarification!! |
![Go to Top of Page Go to Top of Page](images/icon_go_up.gif) |
|
Francesco
Forum Admin
![](images/icon_star_gold.gif) ![](images/icon_star_gold.gif) ![](images/icon_star_gold.gif) ![](images/icon_star_gold.gif) ![](images/icon_star_gold.gif)
Luxembourg
9420 Posts |
Posted - 26/01/2015 : 19:02:34
|
I'd only add that Grammographus lineatus does not belong to the species-group of Demonax notabilis either but to a group of species with 3 black lines, which nobody considers as Grammographus (see BioLib).
![](../public/imgforum/Francesco/201512619159_187348.jpg) Grammographus lineatus Chevrolat, 1863 in Gahan (1906)
On the contrary, the species of the group notabilis shows a pattern made of small triangles. |
![Go to Top of Page Go to Top of Page](images/icon_go_up.gif) |
|
Xavier
Scientific Collaborator
![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif)
France
12085 Posts |
Posted - 26/01/2015 : 19:50:31
|
G. Tavakilian change right now Grammographus -> Demonax for this species. It was just a mistake.
To see the modification, we have to wait the next version updated. |
![Go to Top of Page Go to Top of Page](images/icon_go_up.gif) |
|
nalslan
Member Purpuricenus
![](images/icon_star_red.gif) ![](images/icon_star_red.gif)
China
297 Posts |
Posted - 27/01/2015 : 00:25:14
|
Good to know. It reminds me I have a couple of specimen like this and I have trouble to id them. |
![Go to Top of Page Go to Top of Page](images/icon_go_up.gif) |
|
Francesco
Forum Admin
![](images/icon_star_gold.gif) ![](images/icon_star_gold.gif) ![](images/icon_star_gold.gif) ![](images/icon_star_gold.gif) ![](images/icon_star_gold.gif)
Luxembourg
9420 Posts |
Posted - 03/03/2015 : 13:28:28
|
quote: Originally posted by Xavier
G. Tavakilian change right now Grammographus -> Demonax for this species. It was just a mistake.
Now it is a mistake. No published paper supports the revalidation of Grammographus! ![](images/icon_smile_angry.gif) |
![Go to Top of Page Go to Top of Page](images/icon_go_up.gif) |
|
Xavier
Scientific Collaborator
![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif) ![](images/icon_star_bronze.gif)
France
12085 Posts |
Posted - 03/03/2015 : 18:04:21
|
True, and we have to publish it... |
![Go to Top of Page Go to Top of Page](images/icon_go_up.gif) |
|
Topic ![Next Topic Next Topic](images/icon_go_right.gif) |
|